Sunday, September 15, 2019

Dividend Farming Scorecard: Automated Data Processing Inc. (ADP)


One firm of interest to me for several years because of its position in the payroll process arena is Automated Data Processing (ADP).  I’ve looked at it more than once but have not added ADP to the Dividend Farm for various reasons.  It’s been a while since I last reviewed it and decided now would be as good a time as any to take another look.

The table below provides a snapshot of the factors I consider when looking at possible adds to the farm.  The metrics for ADP as of market close on September 13, 2019, are depicted in the right-hand column.  Formatting critical items in this way helps me analyze my options comparing pros and cons against target metrics and alternative investments.

FACTOR
METRICS
ADP
CCC List
Champion
Champion
Current Yield
4.0%
1.86%
Company Profile
Red Flags?
Outsourced HR and payroll services.
Industry Leadership
Top 10
#1 in U.S.
Market Cap
$10 B+
$69.3  B
P/E
< 20
30.4
P/B
< 2
12.8
Debt / Equity
< 1
6.7
Dividend History (Years)
25
44
12 Month Price Range
Lower Half
Top Half
Dividend Payout Ratio
< 75%
58.4%
Portfolio Weight
Slightly Over
Under

CCC List: The DRIPinvesting.org web site provides the list of Champions, Contenders, and Challengers which is where I normally start.  ADP industries has a substantial record as a Dividend Champion which bodes well out of the gate. 

Current Yield:  ADP’s yield is 1.86% which is less than half my target.  It’s grown its dividend at a double-digit rate for the past 10 years, but it would take 7 more years at that rate to double the yield assuming the price remains constant.

Company Profile:  ADP previously specialized in outsourced payroll services and has since expanded to include a variety of human resource (HR) services in addition to payroll processing.

Industry Leadership:  Forbes indicated ADP was one of the two largest human resource outsourcing (HRO) firms in the U.S. eclipsing the number 2 provider Paychex by a considerable margin.  If you’re going to invest, doing so in a 1 or a 2 isn’t a bad way to start.

Market Capitalization:  Market cap for ADP is approaching $70 B making it 7x larger than my minimum target threshold.  Size means stability so that’s a positive. 

Price to Earnings:  The trailing P/E of 30.4 is 50% higher than my upper limit.  In my opinion the greater the spread between price and earnings the more distance there is between risk and reward.  At some point the gap becomes too wide.  I believe ADP is past that point.

Price to Book:  P/B is 12.8 relative to my target of 2.  Another way to look at is to say that investors are paying $12.80 to own $1.00 in tangible business value.  I’m not in the market for blue sky, let alone square miles of it.

Debt to Equity:  Debt is nearly 7x the equity in the firm.  I’m not sure what else to say but, no thank you.

Dividend History:  A dividend growth history of 44 years is great.  The dividend growth rate, as noted above, has been in the double-digit range, and accelerating, for the past 10 years.  That would be fantastic if the P/E, P/B, and D/E were reasonable.

Price Range:  ADP’s price is in the top half of its trailing 12-month range.  This isn’t bargain territory given the red flag metrics already noted. 

Payout Ratio:  The payout ratio of 58.4% offers considerable headroom supported by a solid growth trend.  However, the price may be outpacing dividend increases.  As a Dividend Farmer I’d rather see cash payments running ahead of price increases the same way a traditional farmer likes to see crop prices rise faster than the value of his land.  It’s easier to pay for essentials with cash than it is market value.

Portfolio Distribution:  ADP would be my only IT sector / outsourcing hold if I were to add it to the farm. Payroll and HR services needs are here to stay, but I question whether the price to pay is worth the cost to play.

Analysis  
ADP missed 5 of my 12 primary benchmarks.  Had it missed only 1 or 2, or even missed the targets it did by slim margins, it may be a possibility.  However, when a company fails to hit nearly 42% of its targets and does so by wide margins, the risk / reward gap becomes too great to add to the Dividend Farm. 

The thoughts and opinions expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional.  Opinions expressed here should not be considered investment advice.  They are presented for discussion and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.

Saturday, September 14, 2019

Dividend Farming Scorecard: Altria (MO)


Altria and Philip Morris have been in talks since August about merging their operations after separating roughly a decade ago.  Altria is a Dividend Champion having raised its dividend payments for nearly a half century – 49 years.  MO is also a holding on the Dividend Farm first having been acquired decades years ago and held for the duration.

Given the recent news about MO, its Champion status, and the nature of its business, I decided it was time to build a Scorecard for the firm.

Below is the card for Altria as of September 13, 2019.  The table provides a snapshot of factors being scored.  I’ll be assessing how well MO meets my targets as well as whether or not it provides a better investment fit than alternatives.

FACTOR
TARGET METRICS
LOW
CCC List
Champion
Champion
Current Yield
4.0%
7.34%
Company Profile
Red Flags?
Tobacco, vaping, cannabis, and liquor
Industry Leadership
Top 10
#1 by U.S. market share
Market Cap
$10 B+
$78.8 B
P/E
< 20
12.6
P/B
< 2
5.45
Debt / Equity
< 1
2.8
Dividend History (Years)
25
49
12 Month Price Range
Lower Half
Near 52-week low
Dividend Payout Ratio
< 75%
95.5%
Portfolio Weight
Under to Slightly Over
Slightly Over

CCC List: The DRIPinvesting.org web site provides the list of Champions, Contenders, and Challengers where I normally start.  Altria is a Dividend Champion with nearly 50 years of dividend growth.  It’s a strong record, well above my 25 year target.

Current Yield:  MO’s trailing yield is 7.34% which is well above my desired target by nearly double.  The long-term trend of dividend growth is a high double digit figure and the payments are nice to get.  However, a yield eclipsing 7% can indicate a level of risk that isn’t warranted if the portfolio weight is significant.

Company Profile:  MO has been a cash cow for years.  It has weathered major regulatory, legislative, and public relations storms while continuing to generate a nice dividend.  One may wonder how long that trend can continue as society here and abroad become increasingly health conscious.  MO has been working on non-tobacco diversification, but it’s done so in other areas that may be as risky, if not more so, than tobacco.

Industry Leadership:  MO is the #1 tobacco firm in the U.S. by market share per Motley Fool.

Market Capitalization:  Having a market cap exceeding $78 B means the firm is nearly 8 times my minimum target.  This is great for investment stability even when the price is near its 52-week low. 

Price to Earnings:  The trailing P/E is nearly 40% below my high water mark of 20.  I appreciate ratios below 20.  The price can bump up quite a ways and still be within the bounds, so that’s good.

Price to Book:  The P/B ratio is nearly 2.5x my comfort level.  I don’t mind paying a small premium, but premiums may come with risk.  The bigger the premium the larger the risk it seems. 

Debt to Equity:  Debt to equity is nearly 3x my max.  MO has put a lot of money into new ventures with limited cash flow history e.g., Cronos, making a Farmer wonder if the juice (return) is worth the squeeze (debt).   

Dividend History:  Growing dividends for 49 years is great.  Nearly doubling the minimum Champion range of 25 years speaks volumes about a firm’s consistent ability to throw off cash.  Furthermore, MO has accelerated its dividend growth rate for the past 10 years.  As with nearly all things, acceleration is not infinite.  Growth is an issue to watch. 

Price Range:  The price is within pennies of its trailing 12-month (TTM) low as of this writing.  That could very well be bargain territory, even for those who are risk averse.  However, the value has fallen by nearly one-third during the past year.  A decline like that could be a real bonus to buyers or the harbinger of something bad.  Time will tell.

Payout Ratio:  The payout ratio of 95.5% is beyond my 75% target ceiling.  MO has generated solid earnings with which to support this ratio and done so for a long time.  It stands to reason it will continue doing so over the short run. 

Portfolio Distribution:  MO is a long-time holding for me.  It predates my start as a Dividend Farmer – by decades.  The compound growth associated with reinvested MO dividends has helped bulk up the Dividend Farm, but adding additional weight may not be prudent.

Analysis  
My overall experience with MO has been good – financially.  The dividend history and yield have treated me well as I’ve accumulated a solid position.  The price currently appears favorable, but the price to book, even at a depressed value, is bothersome.  The same is true of the heavy debt incurred by purchasing risky operations.  The public relations and regulatory volatility and uncertainty inherent in the tobacco industry implies a level of risk I may not want if MO were a new add to the farm.  As a current crop, though, I don’t believe I’ll discontinue farming it.  Instead, I’ll look at redirecting MO dividends to other financial crops reducing MO’s weight in the portfolio without incurring selling costs or capital gains taxes through aggressive rebalancing. 

The thoughts expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional.  Opinions should not be considered investment advice.  They are presented for discussion and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.

Friday, September 13, 2019

How a little equals a lot.


It’s not uncommon to hear people say they don’t have any money for investing.  Alternatively, folks may also lament they can’t save enough to make a difference, so why bother.  Are these valid statements?  Possibly.  Then again, potential investors may need only to sharpen their budget pencils or realize how little investments can generate a large return over time.

Image of empty wallet.


There are plenty of resources available to help people hone their budgeting skills.  I’m sure I’ll touch on more in this blog in the future.  For today, however, I wanted to look specifically at the power of small dollar amounts working over a long period.

For this exercise, I used Excel’s Future Value (FV) function to look at the difference $25 a month can make.  Why $25?  Because that’s an achievable goal.  Reaching it requires foregoing a couple fancy coffees and one or two fast food lunches each month to save enough to clear the bar.  Over 20 years of working life, the difference in foregoing small expenses may be significant.

In the example below on the left, a new college graduate with $1,000 invests it in a few Dividend Champions yielding 4% annually.  In the example on the right, the new grad’s fellow classmate also puts $1,000 into a mix of Dividend Champions and makes it a habit to save $25 each month.  Each quarter the $75 saved is invested in a Champion.  Both continue their respective tracks for 20 years or 80 quarters.

The way FV formulas work, payments into the formula e.g., initial investment and subsequent quarterly payments, are shown as negative figures (in parentheses) while money received out is recognized as a positive figure. 

The periodic interest rate in this exercise is quarterly and equals an annual rate or dividend yield of 4%.  For example, 4% divided by 4 quarters equals a 1% quarterly rate.

Save $0 / Mos.

Save $25 / Mos.
 $       (1,000)
Present Value (PV)
Initial Investment
 $       (1,000)
1.0%
Quarterly Interest Rate
1.0%
80
Periods
80
 $                -  
Quarterly Investment
 $             (75)
$2,216.72
Future Value (FV)
$11,342.08

The graduate who invested $1,000 in stocks yielding 4% and added nothing to it realized just over $2,200 after 20 years.  Conversely, the student who started with $1,000 and made it a habit to save $25 each month, investing $75 each quarter, finished with over $11,300 during the same period.  The second investor saw her modest nest egg grow to more than 5 times that of her classmate.

Now you may be thinking, “Why bother with $11,000+ over 20 years?”  The answer is this is a conservative scenario.  As people’s careers progress and earnings grow, the amount available to contribute each month grows as well.  Of course, having this money to invest assumes investors are disciplined enough to keep plugging away.

What happens if the average amount an investor can save goes from $25 a month to $100 and she continues to make quarterly purchases?  At the end of 20 years she’ll have over $38,700; more than 17x the size the account her fellow grad has.  What if she does really well, saving an average of $200 each month during the 20 year period, purchasing $600 worth of Dividend Champions each quarter?  She’ll have over $75,000 and a sum nearly 34 times larger than her counterpart.  Is it realistic to save $200 per month?

Image of future self quote:  Do something today your future self will thank you for.

The median income (half made more, half made less) in the U.S. in 2017 was $31,782.  Saving $200 per month equals $2,400 a year or 7.5% of the total median income.   Although it may be difficult for some to save and invest that much, it’s not impossible for many to manage if they decide their financial future is important enough to work at it.


In the end we all have decisions to make.  For some, the immediacy of a frothy coffee and bagel twice a week is more important than the well-being of their future selves.  For others, the decision is the opposite.  Knowing the long-term effects of persistent saving and investing can make a difference in the decisions we make today and the life we live tomorrow.  This is why it’s important to understand how a little equals a lot. 



The thoughts expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional.  Opinions should not be considered investment advice.  They are presented for discussion and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.  


Wednesday, September 4, 2019

Start your kids’ Dividend Farm early


About a year ago, my boys received gift money from grandma.  It was a substantial sum for boys in early grade school.  The gift was primarily earmarked for future college or trade school but could be used for other things.  Starting a business, perhaps?
 
I considered adding the money to each boy’s 529 plan, but their plans are already solid.  Besides, I didn’t want to lock up additional funds in a vehicle with penalties.  Should the boys choose to use their gift on things other than education I don’t want them punished for doing so.

Image of money seeds sprouting.
Seed Money
Consequently, I decided to use the money to begin a Dividend Farm for my progeny.  As we farm together we’ll spend time learning about the first seed money planted and how well it progresses between now and when they graduate high school.
 
Along the way we’ll cover basic math concepts, compound interest, the fundamentals of spreadsheets, how to do company research and the resources available with which to do it.  We’ll talk about what can make a company a good addition to the dividend farm.  Comparing and contrasting with alternative investment options will be common.  We’ll discuss risk, budgeting, and priorities in life shaping opportunity-cost decisions.  I’m sure more will enter the conversation as the boys grow in knowledge, understanding, and maybe (hopefully) wisdom.

Image of The Southern Company logo.So what was chosen as the initial investment ground with the seed money g-ma provided?  The Southern Company (SO).  Southern is a Dividend Contender having grown its dividend payments for 19 consecutive years and wielding a stronger Dividend Farming Scorecard than other options explored at the time of purchase.


I added a little money to the grandma stash and purchased 36 shares of SO at $55.34 per share for the boys.  It’ll be split evenly between them when mom and dad decide they’re old enough (read responsible enough) to have their own brokerage accounts.  Until then, it will be “co-managed” with dad while he pays taxes on the dividend income.

SO was yielding 4.4% at the time of purchase.  Assuming it continues at that rate and the boys hold for 10, 15, or 20 years they may stand to split $3,086, $3,841, or $4,780 respectively.
 
These figures assume:
  • The boys (or dad) don’t add to the pot during that period.
  • There is no growth in the dividend payments even though SO has grown its dividend 3.5% a year, on average, for the past 10 years.
  • There is no value appreciation in the stock.

In other words, there’s plenty of upside that can materialize over the years.  Of course, downside lurks as well, but the total upside and its probability of it happening exceeds the downside and its probability from my perspective.  I believe the expected benefit exceeds the expected cost by a wide margin while offering the boys a stable, attractive piece of investing ground in which to cut their teeth. 

Image of Albert Einstein and his quote about compound interest.
The point here is two-fold.  First, we’re making as much use of time as possible allowing compound growth to work its powerful wonders.  Second, the boys get to learn a great deal through practical application – the kind they’ll use in their lives long after I’m gone. 

Building a financial future is important.  Leaving a legacy of learning and knowledge while doing so is priceless.  That’s why it may be a good idea to start your kids’ Dividend Farms early.  

The thoughts expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional.  Opinions should not be considered investment advice.  They are presented for discussion and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.


Saturday, August 31, 2019

Div Tip #19: No fear.

Image of Dividend Tip Jar.
Dividend Tip Jar

Caution, yes.  Fear, no.  Many investors hesitate to pursue their own best investing interests because they think they’ll screw things up.  As Winston Churchill aptly put it:  “Success isn’t final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts.”  This is true of DIY investing and Dividend Farming.

Will mistakes be made?  Yes.  Will they sink your portfolio?  Not if you manage your investing risk.  If you start early and learn as much as you can along the way, the less likely you’ll do irreversible damage.  Mistakes will be small, lessons large, and the time available to recover great.  With time and wisdom on your side you’ll go right more often than wrong.  That’s the long-term key to successful Dividend Farming.

1 John 4:18 says it well:  Perfect love drives out fear.  If you love your family, enjoy the investing process, look forward to your future, and move forward with a positive attitude, you’ll do better than you think.  Be prepared.  Minimize your risks.  Be prudent and have no fear.

Tuesday, August 27, 2019

Hard to farm dividends under water.


“Neither a borrower nor a lender be.”  Shakespeare wasn’t just a literary genius.  He was imparting financial savvy to the masses.

Unfortunately, many people missed The Bard as well as the financial intelligence available today.  They rack up debt like our government, which explains a lot.  It seems the debt load may be due to ignorance.

Image of Proverbs 22:7 - the borrower is slave to the lender.
Ancient advice that's sound today.

As a Dividend Farmer, it’s important to understand debt because it’s hard to farm dividends under water financially.  Every dollar of debt incurred results in additional dollars stolen from your dividend operation because you have to pay back the dollar borrowed plus the interest accrued. 

The sad fact of our immediate gratification society is that people don’t think or know how much they’ll actually spend on debt when they make a credit card purchase.  Again, much like our government.

One way to address this is to learn about debt.  Practically speaking, it means understanding how much the debt will cost you during the period you pay it.  More importantly, how much of the cash pool won’t be available for seeding a Dividend Farm. 

With knowledge, it’s easier to make informed opportunity-cost decisions.  If the true cost of a purchase (original price + interest paid) is known, a reasonably comparison between that cost and the value of the item purchased can be made.  It’s also possible to compare the cost of debt to the investment money lost due to debt payments.

How does anyone, other than the lender, know how big the interest penalty will be so a comparison can be made?  A couple methods follow using an average credit card interest rate.

Wallet Hub’s Credit Landscape Report from January 2019 indicated the average interest rate on a secured credit card was 18.81% so we’ll start there.

Step 1:  Divide the interest rate (18.81% in this case) by the number of days in a year (365 for earthlings) to get the daily rate.  .1881 / 365 = .00051534.

Step 2:  Multiply the daily rate from above by the average daily balance from your credit card statement.  For example, Discover Card claims the average American household carried $16,061 in credit card debt in 2016.  Using that figure the equation would look like this:  .00051534 x $16,061 = $8.27.

Step 3:  Multiply the daily rate by the number of days in the billing period which is typically 30.  This equation would be:  $8.27 x 30 = $248.30. 

In this example, nearly $250 in interest is paid before touching the principle.  Shelling out $250 a month to cover 18.81% interest is a lot of money that could otherwise be put to use on a Dividend Farm.

Another way to estimate the price of interest is to use an amortization calculator like any of the free versions found on line.  An example Excel version is shown below.  Plugging the average balance from your credit card into the calculator along with the interest rate from the card and using a 5 year loan period (as requested by the National Foundation for Credit Counseling) results in an interest payment of $251.76 for the period.  This figure is close to the $248.30 payment calculated previously.

Image of free amortization table in Excel.
Free Amortization Table in Excel
In either case, you’ll sink over $3,000 a year in interest into a credit card company instead of putting that money to work on your Dividend Farm.  It doesn’t take many years at that rate to substantially, and negatively, effect a retirement portfolio.

It must be noted that credit card issuers may use different calculations.  For instance, they might calculate repayment on a 10 year basis rather than 5.  The interest paid during a 10 year payback would be $19,677 against the average debt of $16,061.  Conversely, a 5 year repayment would require paying “only” $8,836 in interest on the original $16,061 in debt.

Who wants to spend 50% to 100%+ the sticker price for anything?  Think about the Dividend Farming possibilities available when that much money ($25,000 or more in the above example) is available rather than paying it all to Discover, American Express, Visa, or MasterCard.

Image of Dave Ramsey quote about borrowing.
Dave Ramsey's Spot-on Advice
Understanding debt, managing it, or better still, avoiding it, can work wonders on your financial future.  If controlling small costs increases your dividend cash flow stream, think what eliminating big costs like excessive credit card debt can do?