Showing posts with label Risk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Risk. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 12, 2019

Risk and Reward: Dividend stocks offer balance


Risk vs Reward Road SignAs with conventional farming, Dividend Farming means you are responsible for your decisions.  That statement is heady stuff during an age in which society often prefers someone else be responsible.

Successfully managing your dividend farm entails making decisions moving you toward your comfort zone along the risk / reward continuum.  Whether we know it or not, we all tend toward a general position on that span.

One end of the spectrum includes opportunities that are nearly risk free but offer few rewards.  For instance, burying your money in your yard reduces all but inflation risk which is the erosion in value of your money while it’s planted in a can in your garden.  There is no financial reward in burying cash.

The opposite end of the spectrum holds risky opportunities offering insane riches.  Lotteries are a perfect example.  You can play, but there’s little chance you’ll get your money back risking loss of your capital, even if it is only a few bucks.  However, if you’re the one among millions hitting the jackpot, you’re set for life.

Parking at one end of the spectrum or the other tends not to work well in the long run.  This is true in life and investing.  Consequently, most of us look for the sweet spot between those points.  It’s my contention that dividend paying stocks offer a great balance between low risk, low reward and high risk, high reward positions for the following reasons.

Total Return represents the dividends paid out by a company plus the appreciation in the value of the stock.  This means you have two value engines working for you – one is a cash flow stream and the other is the increase in stock price reflected in the open market. 

With strong dividend paying companies these engines work in tandem.  Higher valuations are generally tied to a firm’s ability to generate increasingly large sums of cash, much of which is then paid as dividends.  These dividends can be, and regularly are, increased by firms in the CCC list.

Non-dividend paying stocks have only the stock value engine in play.  In lieu of paying dividends, the cash is retained by the firm, reinvested to grow the company, hopefully increasing its market value.  This means that market value appreciation of non-dividend stocks must do the work of value appreciation plus dividend payments to achieve the same result found with dividend paying stocks. 

The implication is that the irrational behavior of Mr. Market can’t upend the cart if non-div stocks are to equal the total return of dividend payers.  In few endeavors is it advisable to bank on hope as a strategy, but from my perspective, that’s what happens with non-dividend paying companies.  Investors hope that value appreciation in the hands of Mr. Market will be equal to the task of value appreciation plus dividends, much less be sufficient to achieve their goals in the long run.

It’s safe to say I’d rather have two people working together to fill my wallet with coins than depend on only one.  What if the one gets hit by a bus?  Then what?  The fact that dividend paying firms aren’t single-threaded when it comes to returning your capital but have two channels through which that can happen strengthens the investment position.
 
Risk is the chance a threat of some kind materializes to do varying degrees of harm.  In simple mathematical terms it’s the probability of an event multiplied by the severity of the event.  For instance, if the probability of stubbing your toe in a dark room is 100%, but the room contains pillows and you’re wearing steel-toed boots, the severity of getting hurt is minimal.  Therefore the risk is low.  On the other hand, if that room is populated with legos, jacks, and hard wooden furniture with sharp corners and you’re barefoot, the severity of damaging to your toe becomes significant and risk goes up considerably.

The same premise holds with dividend paying stocks relative to non-dividend payers.  A dividend stock has two value engines working for it – dividend stream plus stock price increase.  If the stock price declines that doesn’t mean dividends will also decline and vice versa.  Under such conditions the severity of loss is reduced.  Conversely, the probability of a valuation decline for a non-dividend stock may be the same as a dividend payer but the severity of the loss is greater sans dividends.  Therefore, the risk associated with a non-dividend paying stock is greater.

Trade-offs involve exchanging safety and increasing risk for additional reward or the other way around.  Each of us need to consider which trades will deliver us the best possible outcome.  Non-dividend paying companies force investors to forego dividends on the premise their managements can invest the cash more productively than investors can if given the money.  There’s little choice in the matter.  I’d rather a company pay me a dividend letting me determine how best to spend or invest it.  Operating like this increases the control and accountability for my own decisions as a Dividend Farmer rather than leaving it in the hands of people who don’t know me from Adam.

Definition of Tradeoff

On the flip side of the coin, failing to be an intelligent investor while retaining investment responsibility imparts risk that poor decisions will cost money.  However, we can mitigate that risk by continually learning, monitoring our investments, making rational decisions, and exercising patience along the way.

As an investor, you may not feel ready for DIY dividend investing.  There’s nothing wrong with that.  As mentioned earlier, each of us must find the sweet spot on the investing continuum of risk and reward.  We also need to figure out the means to get there – doing it ourselves or passing responsibility to a third party and hoping they don’t let us down.  You can have far greater positive influence on your future than you think.  It takes the Four Things a Dividend Farmer Needs to make it work and the persistence to make it happen.

The thoughts and opinions expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional.  Opinions expressed should not be considered investment advice.  They are presented for discussion and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.



Monday, December 10, 2018

Dividend Farming Style


A previous post highlighted an investment selection process you might consider if you’re thinking about farming dividends.  It’s helpful to understand the investing style or philosophy you want to follow before you delve into a specific process.

Below are several items for you to consider as an investor.  How you relate to each individually and in aggregate help shape your investment style which influences any process you decide to use in selecting investments.  In general, you should align these factors as much as possible before you move down the investment path.

Cash Flow and coins.
Dividend Cash Flow
Cash Flow vs Value Appreciation:  Some investors preference consistent cash flow while others pursue value appreciation of their investment.  The former are less concerned with the size of a brokerage account than with the quantity and reliability of funds dispersed in the form of dividends (cash flow).  The latter want to see their holdings grow in value as much as possible between now and whenever they elect to sell and reap the proceeds.

Risk Tolerance:  Your propensity to tolerate risk influences your investment path.  You may wish to think otherwise, but over long investment horizons, risk tolerance misaligned with investing style isn’t sustainable.  In such situations, you can experience a level of cognitive dissonance seriously affecting investment performance.  For instance, fancying yourself an aggressive growth investor because that’s the style du jure, when you’re averse to high levels of risk, may leave you financially and emotionally exposed to losses from which you can’t recover.

Desired Return:  The rate of return you desire from your investments also influences your investing decision.  High rates of return often correlate with higher than average investment risk.  Consequently, desired return is frequently married to risk tolerance when weighing investment styles.  If you wish to double your money in 12 months, you’ll likely have to take outsized risks to do so.  If you can’t tolerate that kind of risk, your desired return of twice your original investment within a year isn’t practical and should be reevaluated.

Ability to Learn:  If you stop learning, you stop growing.  If you stop growing, you start dying.  While the universal truth of this statement may be argued, it’s often true enough of investing that you should pay heed.  Investors, whether passive, value, growth, technical, fundamental, or any other, who fail to continuously learn lock themselves into yesterday’s investing environment while today’s ecosystem quickly marches forward.  Imagine using computer technology from 1998 to run your business in 2018.  Failure to upgrade and retrain on new systems means a competitive disadvantage to your firm.  Failure to upgrade, retrain, refresh, and continually expand your investing knowledge leaves you at a decided and dangerous disadvantage.  Do you need to be aware of all the latest advances in technical analysis or high frequency trading?  No.  Should you keep abreast of economic, industry, and business trends?  Yes.  

Business Interest:  Many investors don’t consider their interest level when deciding when, where, or how to invest.  It’s just something people “do” because their parents did it, they’re required to do so through a company plan, they feel it’s necessary for social acceptability reasons, or they fear destitution in retirement.  None of these constitute the type of business interest needed to be a successful investor.  Rather, business interest means being genuinely interested in business at some level.  If you’re not, you won’t take the time to learn, even if you’re eminently capable of learning all that’s required.

Time Horizon:  The single largest determinant of investment success is time.  The more you have in which to invest, the better you’re likely to do.  Whether you’re looking at the long-term trend of stock markets or considering the strength of compound investment growth time is your friend.  As with friends, time should not be taken for granted nor its benefits wasted.  Invest as early as you can.  Continue investing regularly along the way.  Keep at it for the duration.  If you do, you can generate a substantial return over time, irrespective of your investment style.

How do these considerations fit within the Dividend Farming framework?

Cash Flow vs Value Appreciation: The Dividend Farmer focuses on cash flow.  As with agricultural farmers, it’s better to harvest crops on a regular basis while working continuously to grow the crop yield.  Having your land appreciate in value is nice, but you can’t pay the bills with appreciated land unless you borrow against it, which adds additional risk and increases your costs, or sell it, in which case it’s no longer yours.  The same holds true for dividend farming.  The goal is to be able to harvest as needed while growing the yield over time.  The best part is that if a dividend harvest isn’t needed at a particular time, the yield can be reinvested to gain more “ground” along the way compounding your return.

Risk Tolerance:  Dividend farming takes a value investing perspective, like Benjamin Graham and later Warren Buffett.  Consequently, it’s fairly risk averse.  If you can tolerate high levels of risk, particularly over extended periods of time, you may find other investing styles a better fit.

Desired Return:  Dividend farmers are concerned with steady and predictable if unspectacular rates of return.  While farmers enjoy bumper crops, they’re not enthusiastic about a bumper crop in one year followed by drought and pestilence the next.  As a result, shouldering higher than average levels of risk to obtain a significant rate of return isn’t of interest to a dividend farmer.  Instead, one should focus on the continuous compounding of the investment crop to do the work while maximally leveraging time.  Downside is minimized with the approach.  However, the possibility of enormous, newsworthy rates of return are normally given up.  Dividend farmers are ok with that.

Ability to Learn:  Farmers are always learning.  The science of farming, weather, technology, and markets never stop and neither do they.  The same goes for Dividend Farmers.  If you’re not regularly reviewing your investments and their activities, learning about markets, or trying to understand the events that influence your investments, you’re limited to serendipity for investment successful.

Business Interest: In line with ability to learn is business interest.  Nearly everyone is capable of learning.  We learn something new nearly every day.  However, business interest means channeling a portion of those learning capabilities into the investing arena.  If investors aren’t interested in learning about their investment style, their investments, or the market in general, they will not develop the knowledge base to be successful.  In such situations, throwing a dart at a board may be the best an investor can hope for unless he’s willing to put all his trust into an investment advisor.  While this is not inherently a bad thing, dividend farmers are DIY types.  If you’re not, then farming dividends may not be the path for you.

Time Horizon:  Time is the single greatest factor affecting investment success.  In total, it’s more powerful than savings, selection, or happenstance.  It offers new investors the chance to learn without causing unrecoverable investment problems.  Time allows investments to compound taking advantage of one of the greatest powers in the investment world – compound interest.  Risk mitigation through time to reach desired investment goals becomes possible.  Doubling your money in 12 months requires a great deal of risk, but doubling it in 10 years requires a 7% return which is roughly the average long-term rate of return of the stock market.  

Dividend Tree
Dividend Tree
Dividend farmers employ time to achieve their investment goals.  The best way to maximize time time is to start early.  It’s been said the best time to plant a tree is 20 years ago.  The next best time is today.  Don’t wait, plan a dividend tree today. 



The thoughts and opinions expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional, and should not be considered as investment advice. The information is presented for consideration and entertainment only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional

Sunday, November 25, 2018

Dividend Farming and Mr. Market


Benjamin Graham, father of value investing, characterized the stock market as an individual named Mr. Market.  Mr. Market would look at companies available and in many cases arbitrarily value each based on how he felt that day; by what his mood dictated.  On a given day Mr. Market would be manic, depressed, or anything in between – save logical.  Mr. Market is a financial mood ring.


When dealing with Mr. Market, the intelligent investor is consistent, logical, and studiously avoids the histrionics of Mr. Market and his emotional swings.  Mr. Market’s antics are largely uncontrollable by the typical investor.  However, per Graham, the savvy investor can control the following:

Brokerage costs – trade infrequently and at low cost.

Ownership costs – avoid mutual funds and investments with excessive annual expenses.

Internal expectations – diligently forecast based on facts and realism, not bandwagon motives.

Risk – mitigation through sound diversification.

Tax bills – hold stocks at least 1 year and preferably 5 to reduce capital gains rates.

Behavior – be wary when following the masses for sometimes the “m” is silent.

As Jason Zweig noted in Chapter 8 of Graham’s Intelligent Investor, “The whole point of investing is not to earn more money than average, but to earn enough money to meet your own needs.”  Meeting your needs while not worrying about the market is the essence of Dividend Farming.  As a Dividend Farmer, you can “put in place a financial plan and a behavioral discipline likely to get you where you want to.”

Ben Graham dryly notes, “The intelligent investor will do better if he forgets about the stock market and pays attention to his dividend returns and to the operating results of his companies.”  This statement is a core precept of Dividend Farming which addresses the controllable factors noted previously.  Dividend Farming helps control:

Brokerage costs by keeping them to a minimum buying and holding dividend paying stocks rather than feverishly day trading.

Ownership costs which are reduced since dividend reinvestment plans rarely carry management fees.  Furthermore, dividend stocks allow you to reinvest your dividends with no brokerage fees further reducing ownership costs.

Internal expectations that can be positioned in your favor by looking at the history of dividend payments.  While past performance is no guarantee of future success, any firm paying dividends for 25 years or more will fight strenuously to protect and grow that dividend record.  Such focus means stability of operation is critical to the company and helping reduce the risk inherent in forecasting.

Risk is limited through sound diversification as discussed in this diversification post.

Tax bills are minimized through the buy, hold, and grow strategy of dividend farming.  Some dividends may be taxed as ordinary income, but much of your growth falls into the capital gains bucket taxed at a lower rate.

Behavior inherent in dividend farming focuses on the time, care, and compound growth of a crop.  This kind of attention is a great way to curb the excessive and often rash behavior of Mr. Market.

Intelligent investing is more than brains, it’s character. Former Senator Dan Coats said, “Habit is the daily battleground of character.”  Dividend farming pursued diligently provides the habit supporting the character necessary for successful, long-term investing helping reach your financial goal.

The thoughts and opinions expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional.  Opinions expressed here should not be considered investment advice.  They are presented for discussion and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.


Monday, October 22, 2018

Investment Diversification: Is more better?


Investment egg basket.
Investment Egg Basket
As mentioned in the post 5.5. Reasons Dividend Stocks Beat Index Mutual Funds, the prospect of buying a huge basket of stocks in an index fund doesn’t really provide better risk mitigation than could be had with a compact basket of 20-30 stocks – probably even fewer.  In this case, the risk being discussed is that your invested funds disappear courtesy of an unforeseen business disaster on the part of the company in which you invested.  The general premise of this piece is laid out below.

Scenario #1:  Your money is invested entirely in Company A which has a 10% chance of going out of business for various reasons.  This means you have a 10% chance of losing your entire nest egg.

Scenario #2: You split your investment portfolio evenly across Companies A and B.  Both firms are in unrelated segments like transportation and health care in which case the probability of either entity going under is independent of the other doing likewise. 

The probability of Company A going out of business remains 10% as in the first scenario.  The probability of Company B going belly up is also 10%.  What now is the probability of completely losing your shirt because both companies tank at the same time?  The companies are in unrelated industries in which case the probability of one going out of business is independent of the probability of the other going out of business.  The probability of two unrelated events happening simultaneously is determined by multiplying the probably of A times the probability of B: 

Probability A (10% ) x Probability B (10%) or .10 x .10 = .01 or 1%.

By spreading your investment pool from one company to two companies in divergent industries you’ve reduced your risk of losing everything from 10% to 1%.

Scenario #3: You think to yourself that if investing in 2 companies reduces risk, then investing in 3 companies has to be better still.  (It is, to a very small degree.)  Therefore you spread your wealth across three companies (A, B, C) each with an independent probability of going out of business of 10% because they are all in unrelated industries.  Now the risk of losing your life savings is calculated by multiplying the risk of A x B x C shown here:

Probability A (10%) x Probability B (10%) x Probability C (10%) or .10 x .10 x .10 = .001 or one-tenth of one percent.

By spreading your investment pool from two companies to three you’ve reduced your risk by nine-tenths of one percent.  The risk reduction generated isn’t large but the added workload in monitoring the third firm is, relatively speaking.

Carry this math across 15 or 20 firms and you’ll see the risk reduction becomes excruciatingly small while the management workload increases greatly in proportion.   

The math means that an index fund with hundreds or thousands of companies held within it produces no meaningful risk below that of a small, selective portfolio of quality companies as far as I’m concerned.  It does, however, generate a lot of extra work OR management fees for the index mutual fund.  Brokers and money managers like that fact.  It works to their advantage when millions of investors aren’t paying attention.

Investopedia does a nice job summarizing investment risk.  Systemic or market risk which can’t be diversified away (think inflation) and unsystemic risk which is germane to a specific company.   The unsystemic risk is what diversification is designed to mitigate.  As you can see from the examples above, the law of diminishing returns is prominent rendering moot the advantage of holding hundreds or thousands of firms in a single fund and paying a fee for the privilege of doing so.

Andrew Carnegie once said “The way to become rich is to put all your eggs into one basked and then watch that basket.”  I’m not comfortable with that advice nor am I comfortable with the current wisdom endorsing investors to put a little money into every basket and watching none of it.  Let the pros watch it for you – for a fee.  With a little work and a few tools, it’s possible you can cultivate good ground somewhere in between.  You can concentrate on solid, dividend paying companies in a diversified portfolio of 20 to 30 holdings, maybe fewer, avoid annual fees, and succeed.  It’s worth investigating, right?

The thoughts and opinions expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional, and therefore should not be considered as investment advice.  This information is presented for education and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.       

Thursday, September 6, 2018

9 Reasons Dividend Stocks Beat Annuities


Gambling.  Annuities.  Same thing.
Annuity Warning
Annuity Warning

When you gamble, you’re putting money into a game playing against the casino, using “house rules”, and hoping you come out ahead.  As most people know, the odds favor the house.  This doesn’t mean everyone always loses, but over the long run, far more people lose than win making the house the big winner in the end.

Annuities are pretty much the same thing.  In this case, insurance companies and other financial institutions are the equivalent of the casino and you’re putting your money into a game with odds heavily favoring those folks – not you.

Why would anyone gamble like this?  Mostly because they’ve been “sold” an annuity not understanding the purpose of an annuity or how it works.

An annuity is a contract between you and the insurance company that says the insurance company will pay you a certain stream of income over a future period of time.  In exchange, you must give that insurance company a lump sum of money OR agree to make a series of payments up front during what’s referred to as an accumulation phase.  In other words, give me your money and I guarantee you’ll get (most) of it back in the future. 

Put in such stark terms, it’s reasonable to believe many buyers wouldn’t pull the trigger on an annuity purchase, but they do because they don’t understand what’s happening.  The annuity contracts require you to pay some form of commission up front, baked into the deal so you can’t see it of course, AND then hang additional management fees on top of that, for the life of the annuity.  These commissions and management fees seriously degrade your “investment”, which isn't likely to be high quality to begin with, but hey, it’s supposed to be a “guaranteed” income stream over time, right?

There are multiple flavors of annuities e.g., fixed, variable, hybrid, life certain, etc.  However, they are all designed specifically to favor the seller in aggregate.  If not, nobody would sell them, right?
Given this background, here are 9 reasons I believe dividend stocks beat annuities.

1)    Commissions:  If you buy a stock with a solid history of dividend payments, you’ll do so for only a few dollars at a time through most brokerages.  Let’s say you buy $10,000 of a div stock through Fidelity.  You’ll pay anywhere from $5 - $10 to do so.  However, if you contract for an annuity of $10,000 with an insurance company, you could pay commissions in the 3-7% range or $300 - $700.  The cost to get into the annuity is 30x to 140x times higher than it is to get into the stock.

2)    Management Fees:  Once you buy a dividend stock, you pay no management fees for the privilege of owning it.  On the contrary, the annuity is likely to charge you a relatively substantial fee each year to “own” the annuity.  Management fees are often on par with those of managed mutual funds.  If managed mutual funds charge 1% to 3% per year, that's about what you can expect from an annuity.

3)    Surrender Fees: If you buy a dividend stock today and discover in six months that you need the money, you can sell the stock and pay the commission which is only a few bucks through most brokerages plus taxes on any gains (if there are any).  However, if you buy an annuity today and discover in six months that you need the money, you’ll pay a hefty surrender fee.  For instance, assume your annuity had a 7-year surrender period and you withdrew your money in six months.  Your surrender fee is likely to be 7% of your annuity ($700 on a $10,000 annuity).  If you need your money out in three years your surrender fee drops to 4% of your principle corresponding with four years left in the surrender period.  This $400 still a hefty chunk.  Under these conditions you won’t avoid the surrender fee until you’ve passed the seven-year mark on the annuity.  What's worse, some annuities have surrender periods up to 10 years.

4)    Risk: Annuities are mostly sold by insurance companies.  Insurance companies can go out of business like any other firm.  If you have $10,000 to invest and put it all into an annuity you’ve put all your eggs into a single insurance company basket.  While it’s possible to spread your annuity funds among a few insurance carriers, it’s much easier and more economical to spread your $10,000 investment across several dividend aristocrats or champions, at lower cost and with less complexity.  Spreading your investment funds across several investments diversifies away much of your investment risk while putting all your money into an annuity through one insurance carrier doesn’t.  We may explore the probability behind risk diversification in a later post.

5)    Complexity:  It’s easier to understand what AT&T, General Motors, IBM, or Microsoft do as businesses, but it's tough to understand the nuances of a variable annuity vs a life certain product, particularly when offered by different carriers much less the underlying investment structure.  The clarity and ease of understanding that comes with investing in a dividend stalwart vs an opaque annuity makes it easier to determine where your money’s going, how you can get it back, and when.  The rules of dividend stock investment are more user friendly than the rules of annuity selection.  Considering the costs associated with annuities, who needs the complexity on top of it?

6)    Cash Flow: Annuities are sold as vehicles providing a “guaranteed” stream of income over a period of time.  In exchange they take a large bite out of the principle in commissions and fees, then lock up your money through high surrender fees for prolonged periods.  Dividend stocks also offer a stream of income (not guaranteed however) in exchange for which you don’t get gouged with high fees or be forced to lock up your money.  While the annuity stream may provide a larger periodic payment than the dividend stock, it does so by returning a portion of your original principle along with a small investment return.  If you want the same effect with your dividend stocks you can get it by taking the dividend stream while selling a small portion of your underlying portfolio and doing so without any of the large annuity fees.

7)    Incremental Investments:  Annuities require either a large, lump sum payment up front or substantial monthly payments during an accumulation period.  This means you have to start out with a lot of cash or a healthy stream of disposable income.  If you don’t have either of these, then an annuity is out of the question.  However, you can start saving for your future with much smaller investments in total or even smaller monthly contributions e.g., $25 when investing in high quality dividend stocks.  Furthermore, you make those investments on your schedule, not on an insurance company’s.  This allows you to take smaller, cautious steps when starting to save for your future.

8)    Fiduciary Requirements: Up until 2016 or so, agents selling annuities did not have to act with fiduciary responsibility in selling an annuity.  In other words, they were allowed to sell customers whatever would pay the highest commission to the agent irrespective of whether or not the product was in the buyer’s best interest.  When the Department of Labor (DOL) enacted fiduciary requirements, annuity sales began to plummet since agents had to take responsibility for the products they sold and they didn't want to be responsible for a bad apple.  Annuity News even documents the decline.  Unfortunately, the Fifth Circuit Court has overturned that DOL ruling to allow agents to once more sell whatever pays them the greatest commission (see notes above about annuity commissions).  However, the registered investment advisor through whom you are most likely to make your dividend stock purchases is required by the Securities and Exchange Commission to act with fiduciary responsibility when selling stocks.

9)    Investment Visibility:  When you buy an annuity, you’re buying a pig-in-a-poke, blue sky, swamp land in the Everglades, a bridge to nowhere, or who knows what else.  You don’t really get to see or understand the underlying “investments” the annuity provider is putting your money into.  If you buy dividend stocks, however, you can readily see how and what they’re doing.  There is a universe of news, stock, advisory, and regulatory filings you can dig through to gain visibility to your dividend investment.  No such galaxy of resources is available to you for an annuity.  Unless you enjoy losing coins in a couch, it’s nearly always better to see where your money’s going and what it’s doing when it gets there.

If you’ve been keeping score on that original 10,000 dollar investment you put into an annuity, you lost $300 to $700 in up-front commissions, plus another $100 - $300 in fees the first year (plus a similar amount every year thereafter).  This means you’re behind the investment curve by $400 - $1,000 just for signing up.  And if you have an emergency in the first year requiring you to gain access to that money, you’ll lost another $700 - $1000. 

In a worst case scenario, you’re down $2,000 with an annuity before the year’s over.  Granted, that should be the extent of it unless the insurance carrier goes out of business.  Then you lose the lot.  On the other hand, if you put $10,000 into dividend stocks spread across 3 to 5 flavors you’re out about 50 bucks in brokerage fees and that’s it.  It’s possible you could lose the entire $10,000 in a catastrophic market meltdown, but if all 5 of your dividend champions went to zero in a single year, we’ve probably all got a lot more to worry about than market losses.  We’ll be living in mud huts wondering if we’ll ever see the sun again.  

The probability of taking substantial loses with an annuity is, from my perspective, much higher than the probability of suffering a significant setback with a handful of solid dividend payers.  You may have a different take and that’s ok, but at least there's an alternative to consider.

In the next post, I’ll explore the reasons Dividend Stocks Beat Real Estate Investments.


The thoughts and opinions expressed here are those of the author, who is not a financial professional, and therefore should not be considered as investment advice.  This information is presented for education and entertainment purposes only.  For specific investment advice or assistance, please contact a registered investment advisor, licensed broker, or other financial professional.